Peer Feedback on Your CV — Guiding Questions

Task

Step 1 — Read (both, simultaneously):

„Does your partner have a specific job in mind?

  • → Yes: Read the job description, then the CV (3 min).
  • → No: Ask them to describe in 1–2 sentences what kind of role this CV should work for. Then read the CV (3 min).

Keep the guiding questions below in mind while reading. No explanations from your partner until you’ve finished.

Step 2a — Feedback on CV #1: One person shares their feedback using the guiding questions. The other listens.

Step 2b — Feedback on CV #2: Switch roles and repeat.


1. First Impression

  • What role or field does this person seem to be targeting?
  • What stood out to you most — positively or negatively?

2. Structure

  • Where did your eye go first — and why?
  • What would you remove or reorganize to make it easier to read?

3. Content and Impact

  • Which bullet points felt most convincing — and which felt like a list of tasks?
  • Where would you want to see a number, an example, or a concrete result?

💡 PhD/PostDoc: Are academic activities framed in industry language? E.g.: Grant writing → Stakeholder pitching · Student supervision → Team leadership · Conference talk → Public communication

4. Fit

  • How well does the CV match the target role — and where does it fall short?
  • What would you cut to make it more focused?

5. Other Observations

  • What else did you notice that didn’t fit the categories above?

6. Wrap-Up

  • If this person could change only one thing before sending this CV tomorrow — what would it be?
  • What is the strongest element that should definitely stay?

📌 Ground Rule for Receiving Feedback: The recruiter gets your CV without you in the room. If your partner doesn’t understand something, neither will the recruiter — and they won’t ask. If you feel the urge to explain what you meant: that’s exactly what needs to go into the CV.