Human vs. AI Feedback — Discussion Guide

Still in pairs. Compare the feedback you received from your partner (Step 2) with the feedback from the AI tool (Step 3). Work through the questions below together.


1. Reflecting on the Feedback

  • What was new, exciting, or surprising?
  • What disappointed you?
  • Where did human and AI feedback agree — and where did they contradict each other?
  • Which feedback was more useful — and why?

2. Questioning the AI

  • Where was the AI feedback generic, wrong, or missing context?
  • Where would you trust it — and where would you override it?

3. Human vs. AI

  • What can your partner do that the AI can’t — and vice versa?

4. Next Steps

  • What are the most imporant changes you will make to your CV?